Christmas Cookies Everyone Actually Wants to Eat

Not every Christmas cookie deserves your Saturday. These are the ones that vanish from the tin, get requested by name, and make a cookie swap worth showing up for.

Every December, the internet fills up with lists of fifty Christmas cookies, and every December, most of them sit untouched in the tin until January. This list is different. These are the cookies people actually reach for — the ones kids trade for, neighbors ask about, and your family requests by name before you have even asked what to bake.

If you bake nothing else this season, bake three or four from this list, bake them well, and share them generously. That is a perfect cookie year.

The Essential Dozen

1. Soft sugar cookies with royal icing: The decorating cookie. Keep the cookie itself simple and slightly soft — the fun is in the decorating, especially with kids at the table.
2. Gingerbread people: Warmly spiced, sturdy enough to decorate, and they make your whole house smell like Christmas while they bake.
3. Snickerdoodles: Soft, tangy, rolled in cinnamon sugar. They are often the first to disappear, and nobody can quite explain why. Bake extra.
4. Chocolate crinkle cookies: Crackly powdered-sugar tops, brownie-like centers. They look dramatic and taste even better.
5. Thumbprint cookies with jam: Buttery, pretty, and the raspberry jam in the middle makes them feel special. Use good jam.
6. Peanut butter blossoms: The peanut butter cookie with a chocolate kiss pressed in while warm. A cookie-swap heavyweight since forever.
7. Shortbread: Four ingredients, endless variations. Dip half in chocolate if you want to feel fancy with almost no extra work.
8. Linzer cookies: The bakery-window cookie — spiced, nutty, with jam peeking through a cut-out top. Worth the effort once a year.
9. Peppermint bark cookies: Chocolate cookie, white chocolate, crushed candy cane. Minty, crunchy, very December.
10. Molasses cookies: Chewy, deep, old-fashioned. The one your grandparents will gravitate to first.
11. Italian rainbow cookies: More of a project than a cookie, but people lose their minds over them. Make them for someone you really like.
12. Classic chocolate chip, holiday edition: Your best chocolate chip recipe with red and green candies or a sprinkle of sea salt. Familiar wins.

The Rules for Cookies That Turn Out

• Room temperature butter means room temperature. Leave it out an hour. Melted butter spreads your cookies thin; cold butter will not cream.
• Chill the dough when the recipe says to. Especially for cut-outs. Warm dough equals blob-shaped reindeer.
• One test cookie. Bake a single cookie first to check spread and timing before committing a whole tray.
• Underbake by one minute. Cookies finish on the hot tray. Pull them when the centers still look slightly soft for the chewiest result.
• Parchment paper every time. No sticking, no scrubbing, even browning. It is the cheapest upgrade in baking.

Storage: Keep Them Fresh Past Christmas

Cookies go stale mostly because of air and because different types get stored together. Keep crisp cookies in one tin and soft cookies in another — mixed together, the crisp ones go soft and the soft ones go hard, and everyone loses. A slice of plain bread in the tin with soft cookies keeps them tender; replace it every couple of days.

Most Christmas cookies keep a week at room temperature in an airtight tin. Almost all of them freeze beautifully for up to three months — freeze baked cookies in a single layer first, then stack them with parchment between layers. Frozen dough is even smarter: scoop and freeze dough balls for slice-and-bake or drop cookies, and you can bake fresh cookies in fifteen minutes whenever someone drops by.

Cookie Swap Rules That Keep It Fun

A cookie swap is one of the best parties of the season — one afternoon of baking, a whole table of variety — but it needs a few ground rules or feelings get bruised.

A good hosting move: put on a Christmas movie while people pack their tins — The Holiday or a stack of Home Alone in the background — pour hot cider, and let the swap be as much about hanging out as it is about cookies.

Start with three recipes this year. Master them. Next year, add one more. Before long you will be the person whose tin everyone hopes to get in the swap — and honestly, there are worse Christmas reputations to have.

Baking With Kids (Without Losing Your Mind)

If you are baking with children, choose the forgiving cookies: snickerdoodles they can roll in cinnamon sugar, thumbprints they can press, and sugar cookies they can flood with icing and sprinkles. Put the delicate linzers on your solo baking afternoon. Give each child their own small tray, accept that some cookies will carry a truly heroic amount of sprinkles, and remember that the lopsided reindeer they made entirely themselves will be the one they talk about in June. Baking in an apron that is too big, standing on a stool, flour on their nose — that is not a distraction from Christmas cookies. That is the entire point of Christmas cookies.

One more practical tip from years of December baking: double the batch of whichever cookie your family loves most, and freeze half before anyone sees it. Future you, on the night before Christmas when the tin is mysteriously empty, will open that freezer like it holds treasure. Because it does.

Shop This Article

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases — thank you for supporting the site.